Peyton Manning v Tom Brady in the Playoffs

Manning v Brady playoff matchups

January 18, 2004
AFC Championship
Gillette Stadium
Patriots 24 - Colts 14

January 16, 2005
Divisional Round
Gillette Stadium
Patriots 20 - Colts 3

January 21, 2007
AFC Championship
RCA Dome
Colts 38 - Patriots 34

January 19, 2014
AFC Championship
Mile High Stadium
Broncos 26 - Patriots 16

January 24, 2016
AFC Championship
Mile High Stadium
Broncos 20 - Patriots 18

Including the regular season, Brady holds a 11-6 game head to head advantage, due to a 6-0 start in the rivalry.  But since the 2005-06 season, Peyton holds a 6-5 advantage.

In the playoffs when it really counts, Peyton holds a 3-2 advantage, including the last 3 meetings.  In the AFC Championships, Peyton is 3-1.